When an heiress disappears from her superyacht and security footage shows her getting pushed, the main suspect has to prove her innocence in this thrilling mystery at sea told in reverse chronological order, perfect for fans of Karen McManus and Genuine Fraud.
It was supposed to be the best-ever girls’ trip: five days, four friends, one luxury yacht, no parents. But on the final night, as the yacht cruised the deep and dark waters between Florida and Grand Cayman, eighteen-year-old heiress Giselle vanished. She’s nowhere to be found the next morning even after a frantic search, until security footage surfaces . . . showing Maggie pushing her overboard.
But Maggie has no memory of what happened. All she knows is that she woke up with a throbbing headache, thousands of dollars in cash in her safe, a passport that isn’t hers, and Giselle’s diary. And while Maggie had her own reasons to want Giselle dead, so did everyone else on board: jealous Viv, calculating Emi, even some members of the staff.
What really went down on the top deck that night? Maggie will have to work her way backward to uncover the secrets that everyone—even Giselle—kept below deck or she’s dead in the water.
Jan Gangsei crafts a compulsively readable tale of privilege, family, and identity wrapped in a wholly original mystery that will keep readers on the edges of their seats until the final twist.
On the last night of her luxurious yacht trip with three friends, teen heiress Giselle Haverford went overboard, and security footage shows Maggie pushed her. Maggie doesn't remember a single thing about that night. Her odd, tenuous friendship with Giselle doesn't help her case, either. But Giselle wasn't universally beloved and Maggie wasn't the only person who might have wanted her dead. There's the best friends with secret grudges and jealous streaks, the father who sees Giselle as a liability to his political aspirations, the much younger influencer stepmom who wants her out of the way, and the ex whose life she tipped upside down for her own gain, for starters. Not that any of that matters if Maggie can't find a way to prove she's innocent… IF she actually is.
Dead Below Deck pulls readers in with a truly enticing narrative structure: Maggie's POV is told in reverse chronological order from the moment she's detained and accused of murder on Giselle's superyacht. This is interspersed with diary entries from Giselle in chronological order starting from the day she and Maggie met. Combined, the truth lies somewhere in the middle (but still mostly toward the end, because this is a mystery novel, after all!) We're able to see red herrings and slivers of reveals come together from both the present and past simultaneously. The only downside is that there's just no effort to make the voice of Giselle's diary entries actually sound like a diary entries— They're just narrative fiction that we're told is part of a diary and it really pulled me out of the story.
Dead Below Deck does a solid job of maintaining its mystery. You may suspect a vague version of the true ending, but there will also be many, many other suspects. Everyone has their own problems with Giselle, and many of those wounds were deep enough for someone to seek revenge. It felt like a new possibility was introduced every few chapters and that really kept me glued to the pages! Gangesi has some tricks up her sleeve, plot-wise, particularly toward the end of the novel. That being said, not every little twist lands super effectively.
Unfortunately, the character development wasn't fully there. The novel felt like it wanted to say something about the ultra-privileged with Giselle, but never fully committed. Separately, there are so many hints at Maggie's dark, scandalous past. It was constantly teased, yet ultimately was revealed to be pretty underwhelming. I liked but didn't feel super strongly about either narrator, both of whom had the potential to be the good guy or a deliciously cunning unreliable narrator, but never felt that way despite some inevitable scheming. The novel still had lots of merit besides, but I do wish the characters were a little more fleshed out.
If you like mysteries and twisty storytelling, there's plenty in Dead Below Deck to keep you on board. There may be some rough seas when it comes to character relationships, but the mystery element is all smooth sailing. Okay, okay… I'm done with the puns now! Seriously, this one's an enjoyable mystery!
